94 Olean St Ste 120 - Trinity Medical
Obstetrics & Gynecology • East Aurora, NY
About
Summary: Trinity Medical is a private Hospitals and Health Care provider based in Buffalo, NY, with 5 office locations in Western New York. Their services span primary care and numerous specialties (bariatrics, cardiology, endocrinology, gastroenterology, general surgery, infectious disease, nephrology, ob/gyn, orthopaedics, podiatry, psychiatry, pulmonology, vascular & endovascular). For the address 94 Olean St Ste 120 in East Aurora, Trinity Medical lists East Aurora locations among its offices, but the provided highlights do not specify 94 Olean St Ste 120. If you need the exact East Aurora site details or hours, I recommend contacting their main line at 716-458-1988 or wecare@trinitymedicalwny.org, or checking the Trinity Medical WNY PC website for location-specific pages.
Clinic Type
Obstetrics & Gynecology
Address
94 Olean St Ste 120
Phone
716.706.2112
hrrecruit@chsbuffalo.org
Opening Hours
Not published — contact the clinic to confirm hours.
Emergency Care
911 | nearest Emergency Room
Services Offered
Technology & Equipment
Team
Insurance & Payment
—
Languages Spoken
Current Offers
Accepting New Patients — null
FAQs
What providers are at this location?
Michelle E. Lewis, DO; Tiffany Nakajima, CNM; Caitlin M. Nicotra, DO, FACOOG; Kristine Sabatino, CNM; others may be available.
What providers are available at this location?
The following providers are available for appointments at this office location: Michelle E. Lewis, DO; Tiffany Nakajima, CNM; Caitlin M. Nicotra, DO, FACOOG; Kristine Sabatino, CNM.
Social Media
Photos
What Patients Say
Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed
- BusinessYab: Generally high on local business platforms (e.g., 4 reviews on businessyab) (4 reviews on businessyab)
- LocalityBiz: Mixed (mostly positive, some neutral/negative) (Not explicitly totaled, multiple individual reviews present)
Patients praise
- Highly positive feedback for specific OB/GYN providers, particularly Dr. Nicotra and Dr. Ulm
- Patients feel listened to and cared for by clinical providers
- Welcoming atmosphere described by some patients during pregnancy and birthing experiences
Common complaints
- Difficulties with office staff, including reports of unprofessionalism and rudeness
- Long wait times for appointments and responses
- Challenges with obtaining medical records and paperwork (e.g., out-of-work notes)
- Limited service scope due to institutional (Catholic) provider policies
- Difficulty reaching staff by phone
"Dr.Ulm for the best birthing experience. She listened to all my concerns and was so patient with me."
— BusinessYab review"My provider was great and staff were very nice. My issues were that I had to schedule ultrasounds elsewhere... and that Trinity being a Catholic provider was unable to perform a cancer prevention procedure... that inability to fully service my needs is reflected in the score."
— LocalityBiz review (Maria Carroll)"Dr. McQuiller is good but his support staff are some of the most unprofessional, incompetent, nasty people I have ever dealt with."
— Birdeye review (Note: General Trinity Medical WNY context)Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].
In the News
- Caitlin M. Nicotra, DO, FACOOG - Trinity Medical — Sep 3, 2025
- Karen Knight, RPA-C - Trinity Medical — Oct 15, 2025
- Karen Lauricella, NP - Trinity Medical — Oct 15, 2025
- Kimberly A. Pierce, NP, BC - Trinity Medical — Oct 15, 2025
- Nicole Wagner, NP - Trinity Medical — Oct 15, 2025
Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.
More obstetrics & gynecology clinics in East Aurora
Comparing your options?
See other obstetrics & gynecology clinics in East Aurora, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.