Live
Read more

Clinic Type

Neurology

Address

300 Garden City Plaza, Suite 312, Garden City, NY 11530

Phone

631-230-6644

Email

privacy@chsli.org

Opening Hours

Not published — contact the clinic to confirm hours.

Services Offered

Team

  • Jennifer McMonigle, MD — MD

Insurance & Payment

Languages Spoken

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed

  • Healthgrades (Dr. Eva Sahay): 3.4/5 stars (8 reviews)
  • Birdeye (McMonigle Neurology Associates): 4.3/5 stars (40 reviews)

Patients praise

  • Friendly and caring medical or clinical staff (in some experiences)
  • Compassionate care approach (reported by some patients)
  • Clean or nice office environment
  • Effective resolution of medical issues for some patients

Common complaints

  • Rude and unhelpful front desk or administrative staff
  • Difficulty reaching the office via telephone
  • Appointment scheduling issues, including long waits or cancellations
  • Perceived lack of empathy or failure to listen to patient concerns

"Dislike receptionists- rude and uncaring. They like to make things difficult - cancels appointments and the reschedules months out, like I’m the problem."

Healthgrades (Review of Dr. Eva Sahay)

"Communication & empathy is poor, staff is rude especially Skylar who is unprofessional. The only staff members that took time to be pleasant & professional were Gloria; Judy & technician-Luis."

Birdeye (Review of McMonigle Neurology Associates)

"Coming here is like dealing with trusted family. Would not consider changing doctors. They always treat me with tender loving care."

Healthgrades (Review of Dr. Eva Sahay)

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].

Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.

More neurology clinics in Garden City

Garden City, NY·Neurology

NYU Langone Ambulatory Care in Garden City appears not to be listed among NYU Langone Health’s primary locations. NYU Langone Health is an integrated academic health system based in New York City with over 320 locations and several inpatient facilities, primarily in NYC and the surrounding region (e.g., Tisch Hospital, Kimmel Pavilion, NYU Langone Hospital—Brooklyn/Long Island/Suffolk, Hassenfeld Children’s Hospital, Rusk Rehabilitation). The official HQ and main campus addresses are in Manhattan (550 First Avenue, NY 10016) and other NYC sites (e.g., 301 E 17th St; 424 East 34th St; Mineola, NY). If you’re looking for ambulatory or outpatient care specifically in Garden City, NY: - NYU Langone Health’s listed locations do include facilities on Long Island (Mineola address) but no explicit Garden City ambulatory center is shown among the provided highlights. - Consider checking NYU Langone Health’s official site or contact their main line to confirm whether a Garden City ambulatory clinic exists or if services are provided at the Mineola location or nearby sites. Key takeaways: - Primary NYU Langone Health Ambulatory/Outpatient presence is in NYC and Long Island, with Mineola (Mineola, NY 11501) as the closest Long Island site in the provided list. - No Garden City, NY ambulatory location is confirmed in the supplied data. For precise services and directions, verify with NYU Langone Health’s patient services.

VerifiedSince 1841
Garden City, NY·Neurology

Summary: - Long Island Neurology (Long Island Neurology Consultants) is a private neurology practice with multiple offices in New York, including locations on Long Island (Bay Shore, Hewlett HQ, Lynbrook). They offer board-certified neurologists and patient-centered neurological care. - Key details: 5 offices in NY (including 227 Franklin Ave in Hewlett HQ), headquarters in Hewlett, NY. Services focus on neurology and related care. - Accessibility: Website lineurology.com; monthly site visits ~6.4k; strong US focus. - Contact: Main numbers include 516-887-3516 and 516-887-0331. - Note: If you’re specifically seeking a Garden City neurologist, Long Island Neurology has multiple LI locations, but Garden City is not listed as a dedicated office in their provided addresses. Consider checking if they serve nearby Garden City or nearby Lynbrook/Bay Shore/Hewlett offices, or contact them to confirm a Garden City provider.

VerifiedOnline booking

See all neurology clinics in Garden City

Comparing your options?

See other neurology clinics in Garden City, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.

More Neurology Clinics