General Surgery - Pagosa Springs Medical Center
General Surgery • Pagosa Springs, CO • Since 2008
About
Summary: Pagosa Springs Medical Center (PSMC) is a nonprofit critical access hospital and outpatient clinic in Pagosa Springs, CO. Founded in 2008, it operates a 11-bed hospital with 24/7 emergency department and Level IV trauma care, plus a full range of services including primary care, general surgery, orthopedics, gastroenterology, neurology, oncology (infusion), women’s health, cardiology, ENT, telemedicine, diagnostic imaging (mammography, CT, MRI, X-ray), lab services, and more. PSMC serves an 1800-square-mile rural area and provides 9-1-1 EMS response and interfacility transfers. The center employs about 60 staff and generates roughly $18.2 million in annual revenue. Address: 95 S Pagosa Blvd, Pagosa Springs, CO 81147.
Clinic Type
General Surgery
Address
Pagosa Springs Medical Center
Phone
(970) 731-3700
Informatics.Dept@psmedicalcenter.org
Opening Hours
Not published — contact the clinic to confirm hours.
Services Offered
Technology & Equipment
Team
Insurance & Payment
—
Languages Spoken
—
Social Media
Photos








What Patients Say
Overall sentiment across review platforms: mixed
- Healthgrades (for Dr. David Shaeffer): 5.0 out of 5 stars based on 4 reviews (4 reviews)
- Trustburn: 3.1 out of 5 stars (60 reviews)
Patients praise
- positive experiences with specific surgeons, including Dr. David Shaeffer
- praise for bedside manner, professionalism, and effective communication from individual providers
- successful surgical outcomes for specific procedures such as vasectomies and bladder repairs
Common complaints
- reports of unprofessional staff or poor attitudes
- concerns about medical accuracy and handling of complex cases
- complaints regarding communication about medications and overall hospital experience
"Great bedside manner. Listens to his patients."
— Healthgrades patient review for Dr. David Shaeffer"Dr. Quayle is an excellent physician. I went for a vasectomy, and from the intake appt to the actual procedure, Dr. Quayle was professional and kind. The procedure itself was quick and painless."
— Healthgrades patient review for Dr. Sejal Quayle"Don't go to this.hospital they have no idea... that hospital should be... I ll never go there... are gonna kill more people than help them."
— Trustburn patient reviewSynthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 10, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].
In the News
- Kate Gazenko, MD - Pagosa Springs Medical Center — Jun 30, 2026
- Shaeffer, Dr. David S. | MD, MPH - Axis Health System — Aug 12, 2025
- Dr. Amber Reiss-Holt: Urgent Care in Pagosa Springs — Aug 12, 2025
Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 10, 2026.
More general surgery clinics in Pagosa Springs
Dave Shaeffer, MD, MPH at Animas Surgical Hospital (Pagosa Springs) - About: Animas Surgical Hospital is a physician-owned hospital in Durango, Colorado, offering a broad range of surgical services including orthopedics and ophthalmology. The facility emphasizes a low patient-to-nurse ratio (3:1), strong infection control, and a skilled clinical team. - Location relevance: The hospital network is headquartered in Durango, CO, with multiple offices in Durango and related services, and a Pagosa Springs connection noted in the user query. - Notable context: The leadership includes executives like Meggin Roberts (CEO) and other directors; the hospital was founded in 2004 and operates with a sizable local presence. If you’re specifically looking for information on Dr. Dave Shaeffer’s role, credentials, or activities at Animas Surgical Hospital in Pagosa Springs, I can refine the search if you provide more details (e.g., acceptable time frame, department, or specialty).
Dr. David S. Shaeffer, MD, MPH is part of Axis Health System’s medical staff in Pagosa Springs. Axis Health System is a nonprofit providing primary, behavioral, and oral healthcare, crisis response, and pharmacy across 15 offices in Western Slope and Southwest Colorado. The Pagosa Springs location is one of their clinics, with a team that recently announced new providers (e.g., Rebecca Hamilton, PA-C) and emphasizes same-day care at Urgent Care. If you’re seeking Dr. Shaeffer’s services or credentials specifically, please confirm his role or specialty within Pagosa Springs, as the available page highlights general leadership and recent provider updates rather than detailed provider bios.
Comparing your options?
See other general surgery clinics in Pagosa Springs, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.

