Live
Read more

Clinic Type

Orthopedics

Address

1870 Richmond Road, Staten Island, NY 10306

Phone

(718) 285-7118

Email

Opening Hours

Monday: 10:00AM-4:30PM / Tuesday: 10:00AM-6:45PM / Wednesday: 8:00AM-5:00PM / Thursday: 10:00AM-5:30PM / Friday: 8:00AM-5:00PM

Services Offered

  • Orthopedics
  • Sports Medicine
  • Arthroscopic surgery
  • Knee and hip care
  • Shoulder and elbow care
  • Hand and wrist care
  • Spine care
  • Joint replacement
  • Tommy John surgery
  • Labrum tear treatment
  • ACL/Tear treatment
  • Rotator cuff tear treatment
  • Quadriceps tendon autografts
  • Hip/knee replacement
  • Knee pain treatment

Technology & Equipment

  • Arthroscopic surgery
  • Joint replacement technologies
  • Shoulder/rotator cuff treatment modalities

Team

  • Matthew (Teo) Mendez-Zfass — M.D.

Insurance & Payment

Languages Spoken

  • English

FAQs

What are the clinic hours?

Monday–Friday hours listed above.

What are the hours for Staten Island location?

Monday: 10:00AM-4:30PM / Tuesday: 10:00AM-6:45PM / Wednesday: 8:00AM-5:00PM / Thursday: 10:00AM-5:30PM / Friday: 8:00AM-5:00PM

Photos

What Patients Say

Overall sentiment across review platforms: positive

  • Healthgrades: 4.9/5 (264)
  • WebMD Care: 5.0/5 (69)
  • WebMD Care: 4.5/5 (44)
  • RateMDs: 4.9/5 (33)
  • Healthgrades: 4.2/5 (25)

Patients praise

  • high level of professional expertise and knowledge
  • compassionate and attentive bedside manner
  • effective communication of treatment plans and options
  • conservative approach prioritizing non-surgical treatments where appropriate
  • helpful and professional office staff
  • successful outcomes for surgeries and procedures

Common complaints

  • occasional long wait times in office
  • perceived lack of attentiveness or failure to identify pain sources in some patient experiences
  • general patient frustration with doctors not listening to pain complaints

"Dr. McCulloch is one of the best! Great bedside manner, took all the time I needed to make me understand everything that needed to be treated. Great results. Great with documentation, and one of the best staff I've ever dealt with."

New York Sports & Joints patient testimonial

"Kudos to the staff at Dr Montalbano’s office! They are the most professional and at the same time, the most heartwarming group of Professionals by far. A huge thank you to Dr. MONTALBANO for diagnosing my hip injury and treating it with an overwhelming result!"

RateMDs review for Dr. Gregory Montalbano

"Spent almost 2 hours waiting and had to leave without seeing the doctor."

RateMDs review for Dr. John C. L'Insalata

Synthesized from public review platforms as of Jul 11, 2026 — sources: [1][2][3][4].

Information sourced from the clinic's website as of July 11, 2026.

More orthopedics clinics in Staten Island

Staten Island, NY·Orthopedics

Orlin & Cohen Orthopedic Group operates as Long Island’s largest private orthopedic practice with 11 offices in the region and a wide range of services including sports medicine, physical therapy, and rehabilitation. They emphasize advanced, state-of-the-art orthopedic care and treat a high volume of patients across their locations. The organization is nonprofit, headquartered in Woodbury, NY, and maintains multiple contact points in the Long Island area. There is no specific Staten Island location listed among their 11 New York offices in the provided information. If you’re seeking care at Staten Island (3333 Hylan Blvd.), this page does not confirm a Staten Island clinic; you may need to contact their offices directly or check for any updated locations beyond the listed 11.

VerifiedOnline booking
Staten Island, NY·Orthopedics

Staten Island University Hospital (SIUH), part of Northwell Health, is a nonprofit teaching hospital system on Staten Island with two campuses (North and South) totaling 714 beds. The North Campus features a modern ER, education center, and medical arts pavilion; the South Campus offers its own ER and specialty programs including geriatric psychiatry and behavioral health/substance abuse. SIUH emphasizes teaching and community engagement as part of Northwell Health, with access to the broader Northwell network of resources. Key focus areas include orthopedics among other services, supported by a workforce of about 1,186 employees. Contact: siuh.northwell.edu.

VerifiedOnline booking

See all orthopedics clinics in Staten Island

Comparing your options?

See other orthopedics clinics in Staten Island, or search the full directory by insurance, ratings, and more.

More Orthopedics Clinics